This post may be sponsored or contain affiliate links, which means we may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. Read the full disclosure.
A lot of moms seem to be confused on difference between Spectra S1 and S2. They look very similar, aren't they?
What about you? Are you wondering what’s the difference the difference between Spectra S1 and Spectra S2 breast pumps?
In this post, we'll talk a bit about differences between Spectra S1 and S2, as well as what real moms think about them.
(this post may contain affiliate links)
This article is part of Spectra breast pump series. Browse around to check other Spectra posts:
- Spectra S1 Breast Pump Review | Detailed Pros and Cons
- How to Use Spectra S1 breast pump | The Beginner's Guide
- Spectra S1 vs Spectra S2 | What's The Difference?
- Spectra S1 vs Super Genie | Which One To Choose?
- Spectra S1 vs Motif Luna | Which One Is Better?
- Spectra Breast Pump Parts & Accessories | Which one is Compatible?
- Which Breast Pump Bags Can Fit Spectra S1? Check out the top 5
- Spectra M1 Breast Pump Review (most affordable Spectra model)
- Spectra 9+ Breast Pump Review (most portable and sleek Spectra model)
The Difference Between Spectra S1 and Spectra S2
Spectra S1 and S2 have very similar specifications.
Both of them have exactly the same dimensions.
Functionality-wise, they are exactly the same. With either Spectra S1 and S2, you can control the the suction strength and cycle speed independently.
The MAIN DIFFERENCE is just Spectra S1 has a built-in battery that lasts for 3 hours (if fully charged) while Spectra S2 does not.
As a result of this: Spectra s1 is much more portable than Spectra S2. You don't need to find a power outlet whenever you want to pump. Basically you can pump everywhere.
Additionally, the battery makes Spectra S1 slightly heavier
than Spectra S2.
And finally, of course, this explains the price difference between Spectra S1 and S2. Spectra S1 is slightly more expensive due to its built-in battery.
Here’s a comparison table to summarize their differences.
Now.., the question is..
Should I get Spectra S1 or Spectra S2?
First of all, if your insurance covers breast pump, check if they cover Spectra S2 breast pump. I know a lot of insurance companies list Spectra S2 as one of their breast pumps.
Next, if you need to buy either of them, consider this.
+ Do you need the ultimate portability, dislike the need of finding power outlets everywhere? Perhaps you don’t have a dedicated place to pump, need to be able to pump while traveling or on the go.
In that case, Spectra S1 is best for you.
+ Now, if budget does matter and you are okay being tied to a power source every time you pump, then Spectra S2 is a good choice.
Need examples on how to use your Spectra S1/S2 setting?
Get this cheatsheet for FREE (includes 5 different settings and PRO pumping tips)
My personal Opinion
I have a dedicated space to pump in my workplace.
I don’t need to pump everywhere while traveling.
However, I truly enjoy the portability of Spectra S1.
+ Having a built in battery that lasts for 3 hours means I only need to charge it every other day.
Note that even during low-battery moment, Spectra S1’s suction strength keeps going strong, unlike other breast pump brand who easily looses suction once the battery is nearing empty).
+ I don’t need to spend the extra 5 seconds to plug in my pump to the power outlet. One less step for my pumping routine. Honestly, when you are pumping at work and in a hurry, every single second does matter.
That’s why I would strongly recommend choosing Spectra S1 over Spectra S2, as long as the budget permits. You won’t be disappointed.
Need a compact hospital-grade breast pump with built-in battery? Check out the following options:
Other Moms' Review
Still not convinced yet? I’ve compiled some other moms’ comment on why they choose Spectra S1 breast pump:
"I’d definitely choose Spectra S1. In my one year of exclusive pumping, I’ve found a lot of parenting rooms without power points. I also pump in the car a lot and it’s very convenient not to be plugged in somewhere."
"I regretted not buying Spectra S1 when suddenly we had a power outtage!! You don’t think about it until it happened and you wish there’s a battery inside!"
"I bought an S1 and it was the best decision ever. With a hands free bra on, you can pump while making a toast or simply check the baby. I would 100% recommend Spectra S1 for convenience."